IDSA: Retracted Mask Study Adds to H1N1 Confusion » Malaysian Medical Resources

Malaysian Medical Resources

15th November 2009

IDSA: Retracted Mask Study Adds to H1N1 Confusion

posted in - Jimbo, - Medical Updates |

Ooops! The authors of the published study suggesting that N95 respirators offer far better protection against the Influenza A (H1N1) virus compared to normal surgical masks have retracted their study, citing statistical error in their analysis.

You can read about the article retraction here: IDSA: Retracted Mask Study Adds to H1N1 Confusion

Where does that leave us?

I think simple precautions is still the best way to go: wash your hands, cover the mouth when sneezing and coughing, you know, simple things like that.

Last 5 posts by Jimbo

New gel effective against HIV and (maybe) HSV2! - July 27th, 2010
More Reassuring Data on 2009 H1N1 Vaccination and Guillain-Barré Syndrome - June 4th, 2010
PTU Gets Boxed Warning for Potential Liver Injury - April 22nd, 2010
FDA Warns Against Sole Use of Long-Acting Beta Agonists in Asthma - February 22nd, 2010
Meta-Analysis Finds Small, but Definite, Diabetes Risk from Statins - February 17th, 2010

This entry was posted on Sunday, November 15th, 2009 at 8:11 pm and is filed under - Jimbo, - Medical Updates. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.

One Response to “IDSA: Retracted Mask Study Adds to H1N1 Confusion”

1
hwang Says:
November 17th, 2009 at 8:01 am
http://3.bp.blogspot.com/_Af0bdmcSXis/SwFs6af6-bI/AAAAAAAAAO4/FzL5zRGcdyE/s1600/h1n1.png

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

up to content »

About
Daily medical blogs by Malaysian Medical doctors and links to Malaysian Medical Websites.
Best viewed with at least 1024x768 resolution and Firefox browser.

Registered Users
Total: 3142
Registration MAY be required in order to comment and to use the Shoutbox

Shoutbox
Last Message 1 month ago
and 6 guests are online.
- Cybersetan : Q&A between MSU-IMS students and Tan Sri Dr.Ismail Merican: «link»
- Vagus : yes archie i'm sure we all want to know stuff, too
- archie : im new here.i want to know stuff.
- Jimbo : I love the new Wordpress 3.0 used here. It loads much faster! Thanks palmdoc!
- Palmdoc : Hello, this is not the place for specific medical advice. You have to see your doctor. Read the Terms of use of this website again «link»
- tommyfktan : Dear Palmdoc, really need to get your advise.. my dad has 2 valves at his heart has malfunctioned and he has been disgnosed with Colon cancer recently, can you advise us how can it be treated.. thanks.
- tommyfktan : Palmdoc, my dad has heart valves malfuntioned as well as tumor cancer, how should we deal with it. Please kindly advise
- Palmdoc : There's no "PM" for our blog. Please use the Contact form. «link»
- oboitoke : Palmdoc, how can i PM you?
- Palmdoc : Pls consult a doctor, prefereably a vascular surgeon. MMR is not the place for specific medical advice - see our Terms of Use «link»
- used2studymedicine : helo ther. my mom has vericose vein.is there any other alternative other than surgery like cream or medication?
- Palmdoc : hello esec, added your link as a comment on the post «link» Do please make comments there rather than in the Shoutbox.
- esesc : Please check «link» for its ambulance service.
- esesc : .Please check «link»
- Vagus : Glutathione injection???? >_< I suppose you could find the device in the same aisle as the Star Trek Hyposprays
- Palmdoc : See your doctor
- mavismil25 : hi guys? anybody knows where i can buy butterfly needle that can use for glutathione injection.
- Palmdoc : Upgrade successful!
- Palmdoc : Updatting to WP 3.0 now. Wish me luck
- Palmdoc : Planning for a Wordpress update this weekend.
- Cybersetan : or alternatively here «link»
- Cybersetan : Quack Surgery Video Clips Updated - See here «link»
- Cybersetan : An update in MMR forum: «link»
- wildorchid : i've finished my btach bioinformatics.. what are my job prospects?
- Palmdoc : @search the silence is deafening.
- search : any msian docs who want to come back?
- xiaolong88 : is there any possibilities for bioinformatics degree holder to proceed master in medical science? i mean in malaysia
- Palmdoc : ranjene - got this from Google ; «link»
- ranjene : hai,has anyone knows regarding ophysiotherapy course in msia
- Palmdoc : Then that recommendation was made not on the basis of sound evidence based medicine. The so-called evidence on the basis of testimony can be attributed to the placebo effect.
- guzz : Dr from Ampang putri hospital recomand TF to him..
- poor doctor : «link» What took them so long to realise this?
- Palmdoc : just masters in medicine
You must be a registered user to participate in this chat

MMR Stalkers
Temp Disabled

MMR Twitter

follow me on Twitter

Archives
September 2010

M T W T F S S

« Aug

1 2 3 4 5

6 7 8 9 10 11 12

13 14 15 16 17 18 19

20 21 22 23 24 25 26

27 28 29 30

Most Commented Posts
» RM100 million down the drain - 79
» Troubled times for International Medical Graduates in UK – Part II - 66
» Only Homeopathy Practitioners Allowed In Hospitals - 50
» Transfer factor: another MLM scam - 43
» MRCP derecognised? - 37
» Provide quality care, housemen told - 33
» Foot detox scam - 32
» Feedback: Providing laptops for IMU students - 29
» On Integrity - 28
» Kugan’s Autopsy : Unsettling Questions remain - 28

Top Commentators

poor doctor (604)
Jimbo (316)
dranony (245)
huajern (231)
UK Doc (209)
LF Ng (199)
Winston (192)
Vagus (191)
ngchmd (160)
YP (157)

More links
We comply with the HONcode standard for trustworthy health
information:
verify here.
Member
- Perspective
- Confidentiality
- Disclosure
- Reliability
- Courtesy
medbloggercode.com

Links
Associated sites
Doctor Blogs (I)
Doctor Blogs (II)
- Shin Yin
- Zhiyong
- Lost Sheep
- Ken Rhee
- UK Doc
Student Blogs
- Yu Ying
- Jay
- Jane
- Lishun
- Chaoticlife

Subscribe
rss comments

A quote for you

First the doctor told me the good news: I was going to have a disease named after me

Steve Martin

Recent Comments:
- An interesting abdominal xray (7)
  - Palmdoc: They were ingested Chinese medicine.
  - haiyent: calcified multiple fibromata
  - dytia: lanthanum carbonate pills?
  - rufusqueen: iron tablets poisoning.
  - huajern: some sort of undissolved tablets?
  - Palmdoc: No, not shotgun pellets. Patient was not shot and not involved in trauma in any way.
  - Cybersetan: Are those shotgun pellets? seem rather large for a shotgun pellet.
- The things lawyers say (1)
  - coke: Apparently AR didn’t do his homework but kept thinking of doing personal attack. The...
- iPads to be Trialed for Use in Medical Education (6)
  - huajern: rufusqueen: are you planning to perform your housemanship in Malaysia? Then I would...
  - rufusqueen: Because ipad is cool. Just graduated and iPad will be handy during the internship...
  - Palmdoc: As an iPad user I can say this is a brilliant product. It would be an excellent tool...
  - mrmusolla: well.. in other view, iPad brightness is adjustable, just like iphone/ipod. Why not...
  - coke: Why ipad? It must be some idea from the particular management who want to impress somebody...
- Quality of Death: Malaysia ranks 33/40 (1)
  - Winston: I think that euthanasia should be allowed, with all the necessary safeguards in place....
- Be aware of health screening risks (3)
  - kAISER9701: “Kuala Lumpur has the highest density of CT scan machine in the world.”...

Categories
Categories
- Authors (4497)
  - - Digg (250)
  - - Dobbs (889)
  - - Doc (12)
  - - Dranony (2)
  - - Fooji (4)
  - - Guest (6)
  - - Hands (6)
  - - Insidermedicine (178)
  - - Jimbo (187)
  - - LF Ng (3)
  - - Palmdoc (2831)
  - - Profizham.org (24)
  - - TE Cheah (84)
  - - UK Doc (7)
  - - Vagus (25)
  - - Yenjai (2)
- Sections (4582)
  - - Blog rounds (42)
  - - CAM watch (176)
  - - Education (90)
  - - Ethics (81)
  - - Events (157)
  - - Featured site (300)
  - - Feedback (130)
  - - Fraud watch (84)
  - - General (883)
  - - Health tips (315)
  - - Humour (300)
  - - Inspiring (49)
  - - Medical Oddities (37)
  - - Medical Updates (679)
  - - Memories (7)
  - - Moblog (5)
  - - Nation (524)
  - - Offbeat news (279)
  - - Photoblog (154)
  - - Quiz (21)
  - - Reviews (7)
  - - Sexuality (124)
  - - Site updates (299)
    - - Site changes (76)
    - - Updated Links (187)
  - - Teaching (45)
    - - Paces (14)
    - - Short Case (14)
    - - Tips (16)
  - - Technology (238)
  - - Training (19)
  - - Tweets (11)

» IDSA: Retracted Mask Study Adds to H1N1 Confusion